
Ever since I was a little boy growing up on the South Side of Chicago, I've always thought of
Damn Yankees as a very sexy musical. The idea of magically turning into the 22-year-old Tab Hunter, and having men and women idolize me, was a fantasy that kept me awake many a night. There was clearly a homosexual subtext going on in both the play and my mind, but I was too young to know it at the time. What I couldn't understand was how gorgeous Joe Hardy could even be interested in Gwen Verdon's Lola with her vampy 'Whatever Lola Wants' number, wearing those black toreador tights while jumping around and rolling on the floor. Of course, he wanted to go home to his nice, safe wife Meg. That kind of blatant, vulgar sexuality was just yucky. To me, only near the end, when we learn that Lola was previously 'The ugliest girl in Providence, Rhode Island', did I relent and allow myself to root for this mismatched couple. Finally when Joe Hardy (or Tab Hunter) turns back to his middle-aged self and he and Meg are reunited, was I really happy, and, of course, in tears. I got to be handsome, virile, Tab Hunter for a while, but now I'm home safe with Mom and Dad. For all its flagrant sexiness, "Damn Yankees" is really just a very tender story about true love between a husband and wife.
Years later (summer 1993 to be exact), I was tricked into joining the chorus of a production of
Damn Yankeeson Fire Island (don't ask how I was tricked) which became one of my happiest memories of my seasons in 'The Pines'. All at once the homosexual subtext came roaring to the forefront. We had one of the best looking and well-built man I ever met playing Joe Hardy (replete with cut-away pants and shirt so it was HE who ended almost nude during Lola's strip). A smashing, beautiful guy played Lola absolutely straight and spot-on perfect. (He had been in the off-Broadway hit
Pageant.) Very contemporary looking gay men played the other baseball players. (I don't think that nipple rings and other piercings were around in the baseball of the fifties.) And YET, YET, for all its campyness and gaiety, it was still the love story of Joe and Meg Boyd, formerly of Hannibal, Missouri, now living childless, in Washington, DC that really resonated with the Fire Island crowd.
Damn Yankees is a very erotic musical about marriage and commitment to one another, no matter what.
The very next year, the Broadway revival opened and many of us from the Fire Island production got together to see it. Our disappointment was palatable. Bebe Neuwirth was miscast as Lola, Victor Garber was only adequate as Mr. Applegate, the devil, (despite, being the lead, he was so under-used that the director took away the song 'Two Lost Souls' from Joe Hardy and gave it to him. That didn't work!), and Jarrod Emick as Joe was just too slight and callow to be a real hero. The rest of the ball players were of the generic chorus types. Jack O'Brien's revamped book and his less-then-solid direction just didn't work. Later in the run, the producers decided to throw the whole venture under the bus (in the now popular parlance) and installed Jerry Lewis as Applegate. Even with a free ticket, I lasted only the first act and then fled.
Now, the 'Summer Stars series of Encores' has given us a terrific
Damn Yankees, which for me, combines the romantic love story from my youth with the lustiness and fun of my Fire Island days. It also, much to its credit, dispenses with the homo-erotic element and camp that mar too many musicals these days. (Don't get me wrong, I loves the homo element just as much as the next gay, just not where it needn't be) At its core ,
Damn Yankees is a musical comedy about loneliness, passions thwarted or overlooked, feelings of alienation and ultimately trying to answer the eternal question: "How in the hell did I ever get to be this old?". (Hmmm, now I see how I got that gay subtext!) Mixing this up with baseball, a Marilyn Monroe stand in, the Devil, a clear, concise George Abbott book and the great Bob Fosse choreography, director John Rando has given us a pitch-perfect production for a New York City summer night.
While the look of the show is strictly summer stock, that element added a lot to my enjoyment (and precisely the reason I didn't care for last years
Gypsy).
Damn Yankees is a show that really can't sustain a full-scale revival like, say
South Pacific. What's there is there and digging too deep will not yield more gold. The twenty-five piece orchestra didn't make the songs richer, but it was sure great hearing them though. Regarding the cast, almost all got up to bat and hit the ball out of the park! (cue the fireworks and ad copy)
I do want to start with the guys playing the Washington Senators. For the most part they looked like they could actually have been real ball players in that pre-steroid era. They danced the rather masculine Fosse dances like men and not chorus boys. Blatant hetero-aggressiveness has its place, especially in the 'I Thought About the Game' number which actually came off sweeter than it might have.
Randy Graff always has that slight edge of irony which adds interest to her characters. Her Meg is no longer a left- behind victim, still lonely, but able to move on. This makes her duets with Joe Hardy all the more heartbreaking. I felt sad for Meg, but not sorry for her.
Sean Hayes as Mr. Applegate, the Devil, was nothing less than astonishing when you consider this is his New York theater debut. Here is one of the few times that television acting really translated well to the stage. He got all the laughs and really seemed to be enjoying the other actors. Looking relaxed and comfortable, his version of 'Those Were the Good Old Days' brought the house down.
The veteran stage actress, Jane Krakowski as Lola looked so stunning and sang and danced with such bravado that it was almost a shock to realize how vulnerable this woman really was. In the second act, her scene with Joe makes you realize that she is just a lonely woman who never had love in 170 years. Truly touching.
Finally, Cheyenne Jackson, as the man-child Joe Hardy, was just not there yet. I saw the third preview and he was still trying to find his core, at least in the first act. All the characters in "Damn Yankees" are 'who they say they are' with the exception of Joe Hardy. Don't forget that while we see young Joe Hardy, inside is Joe Boyd, a middle aged insurance salesman. The confused young man is there, but not the knowing older man. I needed to see both Joes. Still, like Ms Lupone last summer, I have no doubt that Mr. Jackson (who looked and sang like my dream version of myself) will eventually nail it. (Hey, he was starring in
Xanadu only last week, so I'm giving him all the time he needs!)
Dare I say it: This production of
Damn Yankees wins the World Series of Summer Musical Theater!